| Back to Back Issues Page | |||||||
![]() |
|||||||
|
They offered me more money November 17, 2026 |
|||||||
| Hello, They offered me more money Just when you thought things were running smoothly with your team, one of your best employees tells you they've got an offer from another company. The base pay is higher, and you can tell they've made their decision. You don't want to lose top talent, and you also want what's best for them. The first thing you do is congratulate them on the opportunity. Next, take a real interest in the details of the offer to ensure they're comparing apples to apples. Typically, employees know their hourly wage or annual salary. They tend to be less informed about the company's share of their health plan, the retirement match, the taxes paid on top of their wages, or the days off they take and still get paid for. Plus, there may be additional perks such as parking, daycare, or gym membership.
Most employees never see the total value of their compensation. When another employer puts a higher wage or salary number in front of them, that number alone often becomes the basis for their decision.
Let's say the offer is $3,000 more in annual base pay. You cover $120 a month more of the health premium than the other company does, so $1,440 of that $3,000 is gone the day they switch, leaving $1,560 as their net increase. Add your retirement match at a point or two higher on the same pay, or one or two more paid days off a year, and the offer that looked like a raise can turn out to be a step backward when you look at their total compensation package. The point is you can help them make an important career decision on the facts, whichever way they decide to go.
Total Compensation Statement Tools
Now you have the tools you need to lead the conversation with confidence. The Total Compensation Statement is an Excel workbook that does the math for you. You fill in the annual numbers, and it calculates the payroll taxes and the totals, then shows how much the company puts in for every dollar of pay the employee receives.
The Leader's Guide walks through where each number comes from and what to leave off the page, and it answers a question about the W-2 that comes up more often than you'd expect. A completed example for an employee at a small electrical contractor is filled in from start to finish for your reference.
Excel, Google Sheets, Word, and PDF. No sign-up. While most of your people won't go looking for another offer this year, they'll still be glad somebody finally showed them the full value of their employment. Building a total compensation statement for each team member also shows you where your own compensation package is strong and where it's less competitive, which is worth knowing the next time you're setting pay ranges or reviewing benefits.
To your success, Richard Founder, Leadership-Tools.com P.S. The Leader's Guide has a script for leading a one-on-one conversation with employees about their total compensation. It's a conversation most employees have never had.
Your complete tool library, free and always open to subscribers:
|
|||||||
| Back to Back Issues Page |