The Ten-Minute Conversation
Deliver the total compensation statement to the employee and discuss it in a one-on-one or annual review. Mailing it or dropping
it in a pay envelope gets it read once and filed. Sitting down with the
employee ensures the statement is understood, and gives the employee a
chance to ask any clarifying questions.
SCRIPT: GIVING THE STATEMENT
Before we get into the year ahead, I want to review your total compensation statement. This is everything the company paid on your behalf last year. Your pay is at the top, and the rest is what goes on behind it: the company's share of your health plan, the 401(k) match, the payroll taxes we pay on top of your wages, your paid time off, and the smaller things like your phone and your license renewal.
The number at the bottom is the total. For every dollar you were paid, the company put in another thirty-two cents. The reason I'm showing this to you is so you understand the total value you are receiving as an employee here. (Briefly review each section with the employee.)
Now that you've had a chance to review the statement, is there anything on here that surprises you, or anything that doesn't look right? If you think of any questions later on, just let me know.
Edit the script's wording as you see fit. If they find an error, thank them and correct it the same day. If they ask about a raise, answer the question as you would at any other time: remind them when pay is reviewed, what it's based on, and what they'd need to show to support a raise in pay. Don't point at the benefits line.
The question about the W-2
A total compensation statement template highlights the total value received by the employee. The total value will always come to more than the W-2 amount the employee sees in January, but the employee must understand the difference. If not, an employee who notices the gap will either wonder which number is real or assume the statement is inflated. The answer is simple, and it's important to be ready for the question before you sit down for the conversation.
Employer-paid premiums, the retirement match, and employer payroll taxes are real money the company spent on that person, and none of them are taxable wages, so none of them appear on a W-2. A W-2 reports what the employee was paid and taxed on. The total compensation statement reports what the company spent on behalf of the employee. Both numbers are accurate, and they answer different questions.
The small print at the bottom of the statement makes the difference clear but say it out loud anyway. For reference, see the example in the total compensation statement template where is says, "For every $1.00 you were paid, Northline Electric invested another $0.32 in you."
Lastly, the box at the bottom of the statement is for the manager to write a brief note. Write the note by hand whenever possible. That small effort makes the conversation more meaningful to the employee. Name one thing the person did this year, with some small level of detail, and sign it.