How to Hold Employees Accountable with Teach, Coach, Expect

How to hold employees accountable is one of the hardest parts of a manager's job, and Teach, Coach, Expect makes it fairer for everyone. It's a simple order of steps: teach the skill, coach until the person can do it, and only then expect results.

teach coach expect hero: a house with a gold check mark

When a task isn't done on time or the quality falls short, the instinct is to hold the person accountable right away. That might mean a pointed conversation or a formal write-up.

Before you take that step, look in the leadership mirror and ask two questions. Have I taught this person how to do the task? Have I coached them until I've seen them do it well?

If the answer to either question is no, holding them accountable is premature, because part of the gap is yours to close. Go back, teach or coach, and get them on track in a positive way.

You know it's time to expect when you've verified that the person knows how to do the job and is choosing not to. They've been taught, they've been coached and they're competent, so what happens next is their choice.

The Three Steps of Teach, Coach, Expect

Each step has a clear finish line, and you don't move to the next one until the person has crossed it.

  • Teach. Explain what needs to be done, why it matters and how to do it. Teaching might happen in a training class, an online module or one-on-one at a desk. You're done when the person can walk you through the steps in their own words.
  • Coach. Work side by side while the person does the task, and give feedback in the moment. This is where you find out whether the training stuck. You're done when you've watched them do it correctly on their own, more than once.
  • Expect. Hold the person accountable for results. Praise them when they deliver, and when performance slips, have a clear conversation about what needs to change. You're only in this step once you've verified they're competent, so a miss comes down to a choice.  Agree on what needs to change and by when, then set a date to check back so the conversation doesn't end there.

When something changes, like a new system, product or process, the person goes back to Teach for that part of the job, even if they've been on the team for years.

Look in the Leadership Mirror Before You Hold Someone Accountable

The leadership mirror is the two questions you ask yourself before any accountability conversation. Your answers tell you which step to go back to, or whether it's time to expect.

Your answersWhat to do next
Not taught yetTeach. Set aside time to show them how, and explain why it matters.
Taught, but not coachedCoach. Work alongside them until you've seen them do it right on their own.
Taught and coached, still missingExpect. Have a clear, firm and supportive conversation about the choice they're making.

The Performance Coaching Toolkit includes a one-page Teach, Coach or Expect decision guide that walks through the same questions. When it is time to expect, How to Motivate Your Team shows a firm and supportive way to have that conversation.

How to Hold Employees Accountable: An Example

Marisol supervises an accounts payable team of six at a distribution company. One clerk, Ben, made 14 invoice-matching errors in March, and Marisol was ready to put a written warning in his file.

MARISOL'S MIRROR CHECK

The two questions: Before writing anything up, Marisol asked herself whether Ben had been taught and coached. He had been taught, since he sat through the two-hour training on the new three-way match process in January. Nobody had coached him. He went back to his desk that same afternoon, and she had never watched him work a batch.

Coach: For two weeks, Marisol sat with Ben for 20 minutes every morning while he matched invoices to purchase orders and receiving reports. In the first session she spotted the habit behind most of his errors. He was matching to the purchase order total instead of line by line.

Expect: In week three, Ben matched a full batch correctly while she watched, then did it again on his own two days later. From that point on, she expected it, and she told him so.

MeasureMarchMay
Invoice-matching errors142
Invoices sent back by vendors91
Average time per batch52 minutes38 minutes

Marisol never wrote the warning. If the errors had kept coming after the coaching, she would have, and it would have been fair.

Teach, Coach, Expect Works at Home Too

My wife had her own ah-ha moment with Teach, Coach, Expect while getting the house ready for company, and I asked her to share it. Chores at home work a lot like tasks at work, and many parents will recognize what happened.

Here is her story...

I had my 'ah-ha' moment while scrubbing the tub in the kids' bathroom, frustrated over our teenage daughter's lack of basic cleaning skills.

We were expecting company, and I was directing traffic to get the house ready. I didn't ask anyone else to clean the bathroom because I have high expectations, and I knew it would be faster if I did it myself.

We were running behind, and I found myself wishing I could hand the job to my oldest daughter and trust that the bathroom would be company-ready.

In our family, everyone helps with chores, but when it comes to deep cleaning, I end up doing most of it. The kids don't have the eye for detail it takes to pass inspection, and when their work doesn't pass, it can quickly turn into frustration for everyone.

Then I asked myself one question: "Had I taken the time to clean alongside my daughter, teaching her and coaching her, so she would know what needed to be done and how to do it?"

I knew the answer right away. I hadn't.

With a busy household of five, dividing up the chores was the only way to get everything done, and the kids had watched us vacuum, load the dishwasher and fold laundry for years. Watching a job get done and learning how to do it well are two different things, though, and nobody had ever stood next to her and walked her through what company-ready looks like.

Richard uses Teach, Coach, Expect with his team at work, and it had never occurred to me to use it at home. The next weekend, my daughter and I cleaned that bathroom together.

After cleaning side by side with her mom, with a clear definition of what "clean" means, our daughter can now get the bathroom company-ready on her own. My wife feels much more at ease handing off bigger jobs, and our daughter's own standard for "clean" has gone up in other parts of the house too.

For more on building these skills with kids, Leadership Skills for Kids has six skills to teach and activities you can do together at home.

How to Hold Employees Accountable FAQ

The questions below address what leaders most commonly ask about how to hold employees accountable.

Click on the (+) sign below to expand each question. Click the (-) sign to collapse it again.

What is Teach, Coach, Expect?

Teach, Coach, Expect is a three-step way to develop people and hold them accountable fairly. You teach the skill, coach until you've seen the person do it well on their own, and only then expect consistent results.

How do you hold employees accountable fairly?

Before any accountability conversation, ask whether you've taught the person how to do the task and coached them until they can do it. If you have, be clear and firm about what needs to change, and stay supportive of the person.

What is the difference between teaching and coaching?

Teaching is explaining what to do, why it matters and how to do it. Coaching is working alongside the person while they do it and giving feedback in the moment until you've seen them do it correctly on their own.

When should you hold someone accountable?

Hold someone accountable when you've verified they know how to do what's expected and they're choosing not to. If they haven't been fully taught or coached, go back to that step first.

Does Teach, Coach, Expect work with kids?

Yes. Chores at home work the same way as tasks at work. Show your child how to do the job, do it alongside them until they can do it well, and then expect it.

More Leadership Development Articles

See all Leadership Development Articles

Richard Gorham

Richard Gorham has led teams in financial services for more than 30 years, from retail branches and operations to investments and insurance, and he still leads a team today.

He founded Leadership-Tools.com in 2002 to give managers free, practical tools like the ones he used in his various leadership roles. Every tool here has been used in a real workplace and comes with a filled-in example you can follow.

Contact Information:


phone
(503) 970-9777

Email Customer Service

helpsupport@leadership-tools.com

Email Richard
richard@leadership-tools.com


By Richard Gorham
Leadership-Tools.com
2879 Riverwalk Loop, Eugene, Oregon, 97401

Copyright (c) 2002 - 2026 All Rights Reserved

Terms of Use    |    Privacy Policy