Hiring the Right Person for the Right Job
Hiring the right person starts long before the interview, with a clear picture of the job and a plan for finding people who can do it well. How you identify and select candidates has a lot to do with whether the person you hire is still with you a year from now, and the steps below take you from confirming the need to making the offer.
The importance of hiring the right person shows up in the numbers. If you hire someone at $40,000 a year and they leave after four months, you've paid about $13,300 in wages, plus the hours you and your team spent training them, and you're back to posting the job.
The right person for the right job is someone who can do the work and fits your culture and the way your team operates. Skills can often be taught, but attitude and the way someone treats customers and coworkers are much harder to change.
That matters even more when you're hiring the right people for leadership positions, because a new supervisor affects everyone who reports to them. A poor fit in that role can cost you good employees along with the hire itself.
There's never a guarantee that a new hire will work out, but a consistent process improves your odds. The interview is one of the last steps, and how well it goes depends on the preparation you do before anyone walks in the door.
9 Steps to Hiring the Right Person
Knowing how to hire the right person comes down to a consistent process. Recruiting the right person for the role follows the same nine steps whether you're hiring a teller or a branch manager.
- Confirm the need to hire. Before you post the job, ask whether you're making full use of the people you already have, whether the work could be reorganized and whether the business can support another salary. If the work is a short-term project, a contractor may be a better fit, and Independent Contractors vs Employees compares the two.
- Complete a job analysis. List the job's essential functions and how you'll measure success, plus any skills that would be a bonus. The role may have changed since the last person was hired, so ask what the ideal candidate needs to do well today.
- Update the job description. Rewrite it from your role clarity analysis so it describes the job as it is now.
- Set a competitive salary. Compare the pay with similar roles inside your company and at other employers nearby. If you hire someone below market, you risk losing them right after you've invested in their training.
- Decide where to find candidates. Pick where you'll recruit and how long you'll search. Job postings aren't the only option, and some of the best candidates come from referrals by your employees and customers.
- Review applications and resumes. Once you have a strong pool of candidates, narrow it to the most qualified. Selecting the right person for the job is easier when one or two trusted leaders review the list with you.
- Schedule interviews. Invite the candidates whose background and proven skills best match the job description, and use the interview tips below to run each one the same way.
- Check references. Call references before you make an offer, and ask specific questions about the work the candidate did. You can also ask whether the candidate is comfortable sharing a recent performance review.
- Make the hiring decision. By now you should have a clear idea of which candidate is right for the job. Talk it over with the leaders who helped you interview, and once you've done your homework, go with your gut and make the offer.
Hiring the Right Person in Practice
ERIN'S NEW PERSONAL BANKER
Erin manages a credit union branch with nine employees. When her personal banker gave notice, she first checked whether the work could be spread across the team, but the branch opens about 40 new accounts a month, and no one else had time to take them on.
Her job analysis showed the role had changed since the last hire, with more of the day spent on lending calls than on walk-in accounts, so she rewrote the job description. Two nearby banks paid $21 an hour for the same role, and Erin raised her posted rate from $19 to match.
A teller referred a friend, and two more candidates came from the posting. Erin and her assistant manager interviewed all three with the same questions and scored each one from 1 to 5 on five criteria. The referral scored 22 of 25, and her references described her as the person customers asked for by name.
Eight months later, she was the branch's top lender for the quarter.
Erin's first two steps changed the job she posted, and the higher rate brought in candidates she might have missed at $19.
A Simple Interview Scorecard
Score every candidate from 1 to 5 on the same five criteria right after each interview, and add a one-line note for each score.
- Job skills: Can they do the essential functions from your job analysis?
- Past results: Did they give specific examples of work they’ve done well?
- Communication: Were their answers clear, and did they listen to your questions?
- Team fit: How would they work with your current team and your customers?
- Interest in the role: Do their questions show they want this particular job?
Add the five scores for a total out of 25, then compare totals across candidates and talk through any big gaps with the leaders who interviewed with you. Erin’s hire scored 22.
Interview Tips for Hiring the Right Person
Once you know where the interview fits in the process, these six tips help you run interviews that lead to hiring the right person.
Tip 1: Prepare in advance
- Write a list of standard questions about the candidate's skills, abilities and past work performance.
- Prepare a scoring sheet with the same measurable criteria for every candidate.
- Ask one or two trusted leaders or team members to interview with you, so the process is fair and consistent.
Tip 2: Collect the right information
- Look for patterns in past behavior, since it's a good predictor of future behavior. Listen to how candidates describe previous jobs and whether they lean toward being generalists or specialists.
- Don't share too much about what you're looking for up front, so candidates answer in their own words.
- Focus on past performance with open-ended questions. For an office manager, you might ask, "How do you keep track of your schedule and paperwork in your current job?"
- Ask questions specific to the role. For a customer service job, try, "Tell me about the most difficult customer you've dealt with and how you resolved the issue," and note the candidate's words and body language.
- Pay attention to the questions the candidate asks, especially the first ones, because they often show what matters most to them.
- Take detailed notes, and rate each candidate on the same criteria right after the interview while it's fresh.
Tip 3: Keep it professional
- Dress the part, hold the interview somewhere private and start on time.
- Explain how the interview will go, including that you'll ask about past results and take notes.
- Share information about the company and the job with every candidate.
Tip 4: Treat every candidate fairly
- Use your standard questions with each applicant, so you're comparing apples to apples.
- Keep every question related to the job and your criteria.
- Show the same interest in every candidate you interview.
Tip 5: Be courteous and respectful
- Allow enough time for the interview, plus a few minutes to debrief afterward.
- Acknowledge the candidate's accomplishments, and never argue.
- Thank each candidate for their time and interest.
Tip 6: Keep the conversation open
- Break the ice by asking about their experience in a particular industry or part of the country.
- Talk about 20% of the time and let the candidate talk about 80%.
- Ask open-ended questions, and if an answer doesn't include specific results, ask follow-up questions until it does.
- Explain the next steps and the timeline, and follow up when you said you would.
"People are not your most important asset. The right people are."
- Jim Collins
Interview Questions to Avoid
Some interview questions are off-limits because they run against federal, state or local employment laws. Equal employment law is extensive and complex, and state and city rules vary, so check the laws where you hire and talk to an attorney if you need advice. The EEOC's page on prohibited employment policies and practices covers the federal rules.
In an interview or on an application, don't ask about:
- Age. Be careful with the word "overqualified" when you're talking with older candidates.
- Arrest records. Many states and cities also have "ban the box" laws that limit when you can ask about criminal convictions, often not until after a conditional job offer.
- Race, color or ethnicity.
- Citizenship. You can ask, "Will you be able to provide proof that you're eligible to work in the U.S. if hired?"
- Ancestry, birthplace or native language. You can ask about the ability to speak English or another language if the job requires it.
- Religion, religious customs or holidays.
- Height or weight, unless it affects the ability to do the job.
- Names and addresses of relatives, other than relatives who work for your organization.
- Whether the candidate owns or rents a home, or who lives with them. Asking for an address to contact them is fine.
- Credit history or financial situation. It's considered job-related in some roles, but many states limit its use, so proceed with caution.
- Salary history. Many states and cities ban asking candidates what they were paid in past jobs.
- Education or training the job doesn't require.
- Sex or gender. Avoid any language or behavior the candidate could find inappropriate.
- Pregnancy, genetic information or medical history. You can usually discuss attendance at a previous job as long as you don't ask about illness or disability.
- Family status, marital status or child-care arrangements.
- Membership in clubs or organizations that aren't related to the job.
- Physical or mental disabilities. You can ask whether the candidate can perform the job's essential duties, with or without reasonable accommodation.
When in doubt, ask yourself whether the question is related to the job. If it isn't, don't ask it. Following these guidelines protects everyone involved and keeps the interview focused on hiring the right person for the job.
Hiring the Right Person FAQ
The questions below address what leaders most commonly ask about hiring the right person.
Click on the (+) sign below to expand each question. Click the (-) sign to collapse it again.
How do you hire the right person?
Start before the interview. Confirm the need, analyze the job, update the description and set a competitive salary, then recruit, review applications, interview each candidate the same way, check references and make the decision with input from a trusted leader.
Why is hiring the right person important?
A wrong hire is expensive. Someone earning $40,000 a year who leaves after four months has cost you about $13,300 in wages, plus training time and a second search, and the right person makes the whole team stronger.
How do you recruit the right person for the role?
Start with a job analysis so you know what the role needs today, then pay a competitive rate and look beyond job postings. Referrals from your employees and customers often bring in some of the best candidates.
What questions should you not ask in an interview?
Avoid questions about age, race, religion, national origin, citizenship, disability, pregnancy, marital or family status and anything else that isn't related to the job. Many states and cities also limit questions about criminal convictions and salary history, so check the laws where you hire.
What should you listen for when you ask, "Why are you the right person for the job?"
Listen for an answer tied to the job you posted, backed by a specific example of past results. A strong candidate connects their experience to what you need, and a weak answer stays general enough to fit any job.
More Team Building Articles
See all Team Building Articles